Do we all Deserve Hell?

Golden scales on a table with a blurry background

It is a common saying among Christians that every human being is a sinner deserving of punishment in hell. The Christian worldview depicts human beings as wretched, sinful, lost, and in need of salvation. In this short article I want to examine this idea and whether it makes sense in light of the existence of a sovereign God.

I have often been puzzled by the Christian concept of original sin. The idea that a single rebellious action by one man, Adam, could lead to guilt for the whole human race for thousands of years seems somewhat bizarre. I can only imagine that the story of the fall of man must be metaphor – a warning from God that each human being must guard against pride. Either that or the fall is an idea created by theologians outside of Scripture, which has become popular simply because it is a way of justifying the Christian idea that every human being needs salvation.

I have a very high view of the sovereignty of God. I believe God is sovereign over all events. That is to say, we do not have free will. If you believe in free will you are necessarily limiting the sovereignty of God, which I am unwilling to do, because when I contemplate the nature of God I deduce that He is omnipresent and has no boundaries – there is no place where God ends and freedom begins. God is the creator, sustainer, and animator of all that exists.

It is not possible to be a Christian and believe what I have stated in the above paragraph. The whole Christian worldview hinges on the idea that we are guilty of punishment, and in order to be guilty, we must be free. Christians believe God is going to judge us for all the decisions we have freely made. Without free will, the idea of divine judgment makes no sense; nor does the Christian worldview in general.

It all comes down to our conception of the nature of God. What are His attributes? Is God separate from His creation, or is creation contained within God? Is God all-powerful or is His power limited? Is God everywhere, or is there a place where God’s being ends and something else begins? Is God spirit, or matter, or spirit and matter?

What we understand and believe about God determines whether or not we can make sense of the Christian worldview and the idea that we are guilty sinners who deserve punishment in hell. I realise that for everyone who believes in God, this presents a predicament. I have tried to explore this predicament in depth in my essay entitled An Almighty Predicament, which is available here.

I humbly invite you to read my essay, and reflect upon the presentation I make concerning the nature of God and the Christian worldview. I am open to questions, comments, and suggestions. You are welcome to leave a comment below, though if you have a lot to say it’s probably better to email me.

God bless you, and I look forward to hearing from you.

26 Comments on “Do we all Deserve Hell?

  1. Hi, Steven. I appreciate your sharing your views, but, in contrast, I have no problem accepting what is clearly stated and laid out in the Bible. For the most part, I don’t struggle in my acceptance of these things, though I admit I don’t fully understand the “marriage” of election and free will. This, however, I accept as truth as God’s ways are not our ways, and that He is certainly not obligated to explain everything to us. Despite this, the Bible is very clear on many issues, and I’m grateful for the clarity it gives me.

    Keep working these things out, Steven, and please keep sharing your thoughts. Even to those of us who are not of the same opinion, what you say is still rich, thought-provoking, and certainly challenging. Very good post!

    Liked by 3 people

    • Thank you, David. I was anxious about publishing this post as I know many of my followers are Christians (and good friends as well). I don’t want to upset anyone, but on the other hand, the purpose of this blog is to look at all the difficult questions of theology.

      I really appreciate that you were willing to read my essay and offer a thoughtful and thorough response, even though you disagree with much of what I had to say. Thank you so much for that, and for your comment here πŸ™‚

      Liked by 1 person

  2. Some well argued and interesting points in your essay. Some seem to run parallel to the Epicurean dilemma, but with a pro-God twist. Have you on this/these read Augustine’s “On Grace and Free Will”?

    Liked by 1 person

  3. “Christians believe God is going to judge us for all the decisions we have freely made. Without free will, the idea of divine judgment makes no sense; nor does the Christian worldview in general.”

    I wouldn’t hinge the entire Christian worldview on the existence (or lack thereof) on free will. The problem is “free will” is a term that means different things to different people.

    For example some arminians will teach a free will means we have free moral agency. We can choose to either be good or bad.

    Many Calvinists will also say they believe in free will, but that something can only act free within it’s nature. And Scripture is clear we are sinners by nature, therefore we are free, but only free to act within that nature. God is perfectly Good therefore free to only act in accordance with that nature, (example, God cannot lie) I am not a Calvinist but my understanding of free will is something close to that. Yes, we can make decisions of our own “free will” but those decisions are not random, but are guided by our nature, which we are inherently bound to.

    So in understanding the fact which you stated, that God will judge everyone for their decisions, I wouldn’t say it’s that black and white. God will decide who goes to eternal punishment based on their natures. Were they born again? Were they regenerated by faith in Christ? Were they in Christ or were they not? That is ultimately what will determine their eternal outcome. After that, works will determine the level of punishment or reward.

    So suppose there is no “free will” according to the classical definition, that we are free to be good or bad, there is still human nature to deal with, and that is why the Christian worldview still makes sense.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Hi N,

      Many thanks for your thoughtful comment.

      I do indeed think that the notion of free will is central to the Christian worldview. As I mentioned, without free will the ideas of sin and judgment don’t make sense, and surely you would agree these ideas are central to Christianity?

      You seem to draw a distinction between the human will and human nature, but I’m unclear about the way in which you perceive these to be distinct. Perhaps you could give your definitions? From my perspective God is in control of all aspects of human behaviour, so a distinction isn’t necessary (for the purpose of this discussion, anyhow).

      I think it’s a problem with Calvinism that despite the fact the sovereignty of God is emphasised so strongly, Calvinists won’t go so far as to take my position (that we don’t have free will). I have watched Calvinists really struggle on this point, because they realise a God who is truly in control of all poses a real challenge to the Christian worldview.

      God bless you and thanks again,

      Steven

      Like

  4. “The whole Christian worldview hinges on the idea that we are guilty of punishment, and in order to be guilty, we must be free.” We are all deserving of judgement regardless of free-will or it’s lack therefore, as we are guilty as charged by our own sins – and that leads to the either or of where we should end up…kinda like going back to the whole you can’t sit on the fence analogy! πŸ™‚

    When we do something whether or not free-will is at work, we did it and so we must live with the consequences. Kinda like “my brother told me to do it but I did it so its still my fault cause ultimately I was in control and had a mind to think and reason my actions through. πŸ™‚ I dunno…just my thoughts.

    Liked by 2 people

  5. Hi Steven, I started reading your essay, but have not finished it (the font is very small on my phone). I will try to finish it when I can.

    My overarching impression is that God is using your spiritual restlessness as a ministry to others who may have similar struggles. Your blog feels like a safe place for people to share contrarian views, without fear of harsh rebuke.

    I keep going back to Job 38-41 as I ponder your recent post. There are many things about God which we will never understand in this lifetime, and we are not guaranteed to get all (or any) of our questions answered, either.

    However, my main point this: I’ve said it before (as have other readers), but keep asking your questions, Steven. Just don’t assume – and I do not think that you ever do – that the answer will come in a particular way or form, if it comes at all. There can be a tension between knowledge and trust, and we all struggle with it in one way or another.

    I will let you know when I complete the essay – likely when I am on my laptop (not my phone!). Take care. ✝️

    Liked by 2 people

    • Hi Daily!

      Thank you so much for such a kind and heartfelt comment πŸ™‚

      Please don’t give yourself eyestrain trying to read me essay on your phone! But I’m really grateful that you decided to download it and have a read – it will really help you to see where I’m coming from.

      Hope you have a wonderful weekend my dear friend, and thanks again for your open mind and encouraging words.

      Peace and blessings,

      Steven

      Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply to Daily Thankful Cancel reply

Please log in using one of these methods to post your comment:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

<span>%d</span> bloggers like this: